New York Rep. Jerry Nadler was accused of hypocrisy for opposing cell phone towers in the area

“Not in my yard,” says one of many metropolis’s most distinguished liberal politicians after town proposed a 32-foot mobile phone tower in Higher East Aspect.

Consultant Jerry Nadler — which demanded metropolis officers shut down Rikers IslandCo-sign a letter It was despatched to town’s Landmarks Preservation Fee opposing the development of dozens of mobile phone towers in historic districts alongside Park Avenue, Carnegie Hill, and UES Historic Districts.

The letter was co-signed by Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine, Senator Liz Kruger, Meeting members Alex Burris and Rebecca Searight and Council members Keith Powers and Julie Menen.

The Higher East Aspect is not the one neighborhood affected. Mayor Eric Adams’ administration — by its Workplace of Expertise and Innovation — is overseeing the set up of two,000 Link5G avenue towers throughout town to spice up service — together with 18 on Group Board 8 on UES, together with 12 in landmark districts.

“At present, I be a part of fellow elected officers on the East Aspect who’ve raised issues concerning the placement of 5G cell towers in our historic neighborhoods with out cautious consideration of their impression on society,” Nadler mentioned in a press release on Twitter.


Representative Jerry Nadler.
Rep. Jerry Nadler opposes putting in 32-foot mobile phone towers on the Higher East Aspect.
Stephen Jeremiah for the NY Submit

Cell phone tower 32 feet.
The 32-foot-tall mobile phone tower that is been put in throughout town and confronted by politicians and residents of the Higher East Aspect.
Samuel Riegelhaupt / Ciba USA

“Whereas the undertaking goals to increase town’s 5G infrastructure, the proposed 32-foot towers don’t mix with the prevailing ones on the Higher East Aspect and have sparked widespread concern all through the neighborhood,” the letter learn.

“We’re involved about transferring ahead with a undertaking that can have a everlasting existence with out exhausting information to substantiate the precise want for these towers,” Paul mentioned.

Nadler represents Manhattan’s Higher East Aspect in addition to the West Aspect for the primary time after congressional redistricting final yr and After defeating him ex rep. Caroline Maloney within the Democratic major.


Eric Adams.
Mayor Eric Adams mentioned putting in 32-foot mobile phone towers is critical to spice up broadband service all through town.
Stephen Yang

NIMBY’s liberal marketing campaign to ban cellphone towers has drawn astonishment and cries of hypocrisy from different political activists involved about crime and extra severe quality-of-life points.

“Cell phone towers are disapproved of, however is it okay to be in jail in Chinatown?”

A neighborhood jail will open in Chinatown if the Rikers Island jail advanced closes as deliberate.

Political marketing consultant Hank Shenkopf, who resides within the Higher West Aspect of the Nadler District, known as his opposition to mobile phone towers “hypocritical and cynical.”

Now we have individuals pooping and peeing on the street. Now we have elevated crime, mentioned Shinkov.

“That is one of the best Nadler can do? Towards the cellphone towers which can be all around the metropolis. Solely poor neighborhoods are speculated to get cellphone towers? What’s improper with this man?”


Cell Phone Tower, John Starks Kia Car Dealership.
A mobile phone tower has been put in in entrance of Knicks basketball nice John Stark’s dealership.
Steve Fago

The liberal opposition is paying homage to the time The Kennedy household opposed — and helped defeat — a deliberate offshore wind farm close to their summer time compound on Cape Cod.

“Accessible broadband and cellphone service is not a luxurious — it is a necessity,” mentioned Adams, when saying the Link5G program final July.

“With regards to digital providers, we all know that far too many New Yorkers have been left behind,” he mentioned.. “Our administration is dedicated to altering that and making certain that every one residents of our metropolis have entry to expertise providers, irrespective of the place they dwell.”

Politicians and residents of UES aren’t the one ones ranting about 5G towers.

ex nix Basketball star John Starks He objected when town had one in all its 32-foot 5G towers in entrance of a Kia dealership in Queens.

Requested about criticism from Nadler and different Higher East lawmakers, a spokesperson for town’s Workplace of Expertise and Innovation mentioned, “This administration believes that digital connectivity is a human proper, important to full participation and entry to alternative in fashionable society.

“As a part of our metropolis’s ongoing efforts to bridge the digital divide, Link5G ensures dependable, blazing-fast community pace and equitably expanded cell protection throughout the 5 boroughs. We thank the elected leaders and neighborhood members for sharing their invaluable suggestions and stay up for persevering with to have interaction with them as we proceed the method of finding these cubicles.”

Leave a Comment